The FBI will not intimidate us to stifle our freedom of speech

Students for Justice in Palestine National Solidarity Statement on Impact of Grand Jury Subpoenas on Students’ First Amendment Rights

December 29, 2010

“For if they take you in the morning, they will be coming for us that night.”

– James Baldwin, in an open letter to Angela Davis, November 19, 1970

As students at over fifty American universities, we unequivocally condemn the abuse of grand jury subpoenas to chill the exercise of First Amendment rights by university students and anti-war activists speaking and organizing against Israel’s continued oppression of the Palestinian people. Since September 24, 2010, the F.B.I. has served at least 24 grand jury subpoenas on students and activists in a secret investigation that many have called a witch-hunt. We call upon Attorney General Eric Holder and United States Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald to respect the civil rights and free speech of all those who support the Palestinian struggle for freedom by immediately withdrawing grand jury subpoenas which threaten the First Amendment rights of students and activists around the country.

The government’s assault on organizations and individuals who support the Palestinian struggle for freedom has become increasingly authoritarian. The abuse of laws criminalizing “material support for terrorism” is unprecedented and, had they been implemented at the time of South African apartheid, would have effectively criminalized broad American support for the anti-apartheid movement. At the apparent behest of US Attorney Patrick Fitzgerald, the government today has cast a net so wide that it has entangled journalists, college students, and peace activists. We know that a campaign so indiscriminate will seriously impinge on the First Amendment and other civil rights of people living in the United States. This will, in particular, affect active and outspoken students on university campuses, especially those of Palestinian descent.

It is not only our right but also our moral duty to speak and act against American foreign policy and its destructive impact on innocent people around the world. Today, America unfortunately stands behind Israel’s oppression of the Palestinian people with money, weaponry, and diplomatic support. We seek to reverse this situation so that American foreign policy stands on the side of people who work towards justice. We reject the government’s efforts to isolate the Palestinian people by severing them from their non-violent supporters abroad. Therefore we stand in solidarity with the victims of our government’s campaign both in America and around the globe.

If Attorney Fitzgerald’s campaign marks the morning of a new day, then we are certain of what awaits us in the night. Like Baldwin before us, we live in an age in which silence is not only criminal but suicidal – we shall, therefore, make as much noise as we can.


American University, Students for Justice in Palestine
Arizona State University
, Students for Justice in Palestine
Bard College
, International Solidarity Movement
Benedictine University
, Students for Justice in Palestine
Boston University
, Students for Justice in Palestine
Brandeis University
, Brandeis SJP
Brooklyn College CUNY
, The Palestinian Club
Columbia University
, Students for Justice in Palestine
Cornell University
, United for Peace and Justice in Palestine
DePaul University
, Students for Justice in Palestine
Eastern Washington University
Florida International University
, Students for Justice in Palestine
George Mason University
, Students for Justice in Palestine
George Washington University
, Students for Justice in Palestine
Georgetown University
, Students for Justice in Palestine
Hampshire College
, Students for Justice in Palestine
Harvard Law School
, Middle East Law Students Association
Harvard University
, Alliance for Justice in the Middle East
Harvard University
, Harvard College Palestine Solidarity Committee
Harvard University
, Harvard Law School Justice for Palestine
Hunter College
, Students for Justice in Palestine
Loyola University
, Middle Eastern Student Association
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
, Palestine@MIT
New York University
, Students for Justice in Palestine
Northeastern Illinois University
, Students for Justice in Palestine
Northwestern University
, Students for Justice in Palestine
Ohio State University
, Committee for Justice in Palestine
Pennsylvania State University
, Students for Justice in Palestine
Rutgers University – New Brunswick
, BAKA: Students United for Middle Eastern Justice
San Diego State University
, Students for Justice in Palestine
School of the Art Institute of Chicago
, Students for Justice in Palestine
Temple University,
Temple Students for Justice in Palestine
Tufts University
, Students for Justice in Palestine
University of Arizona
, Students for Justice in Palestine
University of California, Berkeley
, Students for Justice in Palestine
University of California, Berkeley Law
, Law Students for Justice in Palestine
University of California, Davis
, Students for Justice in Palestine
University of California, Irvine
, Students for Justice in Palestine
University of California, Los Angeles
, Students for Justice in Palestine
University of California, Riverside
, Students for Justice in Palestine
University of California, San Diego
, Students for Justice in Palestine
University of Chicago
, Students for Justice in Palestine
University of Florida
, Students for Justice In Palestine
University of Illinois at Chicago
, Students for Justice in Palestine
University of Maryland, Baltimore County
, Students for Justice in Palestine
University of Michigan
, Students Allied for Freedom & Equality
University of Nebraska, Lincoln
, Palestine Solidarity Committee
University of Pittsburgh
, Pitt Students for Justice in Palestine
University of South Florida
, Students for Justice in Palestine
University of Southern California
, Students for Justice in Palestine
University of Texas at Austin
, Palestine Solidarity Committee
University of Washington
, Students for Justice in Palestine
Vermont Law School
, Law Students for Justice in Palestine
Wellesley College
, Justice for Palestine
Yale University
, Yale Students for Justice and Peace in Palestine

Students denounce demonization of student activism by Anti-Defamation League

On campuses around the country, groups promoting Palestinian freedom respond to attack by the Anti-Defamation League
UNITED STATES (October 17, 2010) – Representing campus organizations at over 60 campuses around the country, university students promoting Palestinian freedom have responded to a vilifying report by the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) listing “Students for Justice in Palestine” (SJP) and a variety of other American organizations as the “Top 10 Anti-Israel Groups in America.”  The report was released the same day the ADL honored Rupert Murdoch, the media mogul who owns Fox News Network.

The report – which also names prominent Muslim-American organizations, Jewish Voice for Peace, and the Christian ecumenical organization Friends of Sabeel – criticizes SJP chapters for “regularly organiz[ing] activities presenting a biased view of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, including mock ‘apartheid walls’ and ‘checkpoint’ displays.” SJP chapters have independently proliferated across the country as awareness about the brutality and violence of Israel’s occupation grows on university campuses. In an unprecedented statement, 60 student groups around the country affirmed, “we are unified by our purpose of confronting these wrongs that cause so much death and suffering.”
Recent investigations by the United Nations and reports by human rights organizations including Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch frequently criticize unrelenting Israeli settlement expansion, the siege of Gaza, the military occupation of the West Bank and East Jerusalem, and brutal Israeli violence that has killed thousands of Palestinian civilians. Ilana Rossoff, from Hampshire College SJP, continued, “We see the urgent need to educate our communities about the injustice of the occupation and work to hold our communities and governments accountable for our own complicity in US support of the occupation.”

The signatory groups affirmed that they were dedicated to non-violent activities, such as promoting Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions in solidarity with the call from over 170 Palestinian civil society organizations. The groups explained, “we locate ourselves in a legacy of social justice movements working for a free and just world.” The groups invited the ADL “to reflect and to choose to build this world, rather than to stop it.”

See the “Joint Statement on Anti-Defamation League’s ‘Top 10’ List” at this url



Yaman Salahi [Connecticut]: 203-491-0092,

Alex Cachinero-Gorman [Massachusetts]: 908-705-6033,


Andrew Dalack [Michigan]:734-645-6860,

Sami Kishawi [Illinois]:773-822-8157,


Lana Khoury [California] 650-274-9085,

Gabriel Schivone [Arizona]: 520-302-6006,

Study abroad program sends wrong message

ASU’s Study Abroad Office announced an Israel study abroad program in conjunction with Ben-Gurion University last month.

However, a partnership with BGU also means inadvertently cooperating with its controversial apartheid policies.

Perhaps the administrators didn’t know of BGU’s reputation of discriminatory procedures, or they simply brushed it off. Regardless, the name of ASU does not need to be mixed with a university that supports prejudice and racist policies.

Ben-Gurion was the first Israeli Prime Minister and the person who read the Israeli Declaration of Independence in 1948. He was once quoted as saying, “Zionism is a transfer of the Jews.”

The concept of “transferring” European Jews to Palestine and then “transferring” Palestinians out is central to Zionism. The “Law of Return” helps grant a right of immigration to Jews born anywhere in the world. This is coupled with “Absentee Property Law” that classifies the personal property of Palestinians as “absentee property” and places it under control of the government.

There was always historic, strong solidarity between South Africans and Palestinians because of the similarities of racist laws that legalized stealing of land in South African and Palestinian territories during Apartheid.

More attention came to this issue when a delegation of South African Veterans of the anti-apartheid struggle was sent to the West Bank in 2008. They agreeably concluded that restrictions endured by Palestinians in the Israeli-occupied territories were worse than those imposed on the black majority under white rule in South Africa.

A South African campaign initiated at the prestigious University of Johannesburg to cut off academic links with Ben-Gurion University is currently gaining momentum.

The apartheid Israeli occupation of the Palestinian territories has had disastrous effects on access to education for Palestinians, which leads to more immobilization, poverty, gendered violence, harassment and humiliation. The racist divide put between “white” and “black” Jews officially exist in state decisions. Several months ago, a religious school in the illegal Israeli settlement of Immanuel was approved funding by the Israeli Education Ministry for segregating white Jewish students from non-white Jewish students in classes.

Israel has also explicitly mounted direct attacks on Palestinian educational institutions, with complete closures of Hebron University and the targeting and bombing of more than 60 schools during the attacks on Gaza in 2009. Meanwhile, BGU maintained structural support for the Israeli occupation by offering scholarships and extra tuition to students who served in active combat units during those attacks.

The assault on Gaza in 2009 resulted in the death of 1,400 Palestinians in acts described by Judge Richard Goldstone as war crimes. The majority of those killed were children and women that died because of indiscriminate Israeli shooting.

The U.N. Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights released a report detailing how Palestinian applicants are three times more likely to be rejected by Israeli academic institutions, including BGU, than Jewish applicants. While Palestinian citizens of Israel constitute more than 20 percent of the country’s population, only a mere 1 percent of the academic staff in Israeli academic institutions are Palestinian.

In regards to academic freedom, BGU has been condemned for disciplining academic staff, such as Professor Neve Gordon, for supporting the non-violent demonstrations. It also went to the extent of maintaining obstacles that prevent students from mounting legal political demonstrations on campus.

At ASU we don’t criminalize political dissent, nor do we support racist and discriminatory policies against Palestinians, Ethiopian Jews, non-Jews or anyone. But our cooperation with such a university sends the wrong message about policies that go against our values.

I call for a review of this decision and urge administrators to disband academic connections with Ben-Gurion University for its lack of respect for human rights and dignity.

This article is from the State Press

SJP Member receives local coverage on Palestine trip

Danielle Back had read about the Palestinian/Israeli conflict and studied the history of that region of the world.

This summer she had a chance to experience what was happening there firsthand.

Back, a junior at Arizona State University spent three weeks in Israel, the West Bank and Gaza, as part of a delegation organized by Interfaith Peace-Builders and the American Friends Service Committee. The delegation met with Israeli and Palestinian groups representing a wide cross-section of both societies.

She said her trip helped make the things she had read or heard about seem real.

“To go there it affects you so much,” Back said. “You hear about these things, but to actually see them, it makes your realize that the Palestinian plight is not exaggerated.”

Back, who spent much of her childhood in Chandler, has no real ties to the Middle East. She said her interest in the Palestinian cause has grown out of studying the U.S. government and its influence in world affairs.

She’s a member of the Barrett Honors College at ASU and is majoring in economics while pursuing a certificate in Arabic studies. Her first trip to an Arabic country was in summer 2009 when she traveled to Morocco to study the language on a scholarship from the U.S. State Department and the Council of American Overseas Research Centers.

While Back’s sympathies lie more closely with the Palestinian point of view, she said the trip also allowed her to see the Israeli side of the conflict more clearly.

“Going there, I definitely sympathize with their fear and with the pain that they have suffered. It did humanize the conflict for me, but the fact still remains that the situation is not equal.”

Back said the difference in resources available to the Israeli government – due at least in part to the support of the United States – made it hard for the two sides to negotiate on an equal level.

Back said they learned of issues such as home evictions in the Palestinian community and the fear Israelis have of rocket attacks.

“It’s more frustrating now because I know people there,” Back said. “We had home stays with Palestinian families. We had a home stay in a city close to Jerusalem with an Israeli family as well. I made friends with a (Israeli) soldier I met on a bus. I have friends on both sides.”

Read more:

Deconstructing the Gaza blockade

From Click here for link

By Oday Shahin August 23, 2010 at 6:27 pm

A ship carrying women activists who hoped to deliver aid to Palestinians through the Israeli blockade along the Gaza Strip will no longer travel to Cyprus from Lebanon, effective Sunday, according to a Saturday report from Reuters.

To some, this may seem like just another grievance to add to the long list of ills caused by the Gaza blockade, but maybe it’s time for people to see a different side of the story — one barely covered by U.S. media.

Beyond the occupation of Palestine since 1967, Israel imposed an unyielding blockade in 2007 meant to cut off the Palestinian-occupied Gaza Strip. Three years have passed, and the blockade has evolved into a man-made humanitarian disaster. In large part, the U.S. government and media have turned a blind eye to the situation. But, according to the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, Navi Pillay, the blockade violates all standards of international humanitarian laws and must be lifted.

The blockade does nothing to “secure” Israel, as denying access to food and medical supplies will only expand the rift between Palestinians and Israelis. However, both sides accepted the Obama administration’s invitation to begin a peace talk two weeks from last Saturday, Israel still controls all of Gaza’s borders, airspace and the freedom of movement, goods and thus the economy.

In the Palestinian parliamentary elections of 2006, the Hamas political party won the majority of seats. When it assumed power the next month Israel, the US and the European Union refused to recognize the party’s right to govern.

Hamas and other factions decided that if Israel broke the six-month cease-fire after Obama’s election, they wouldn’t recognize the authority given by the people, nor let Gaza live, the use of force was its only way of expressing resistance. So Hamas created homemade, uncontrollable rockets from available scrap metal. There was no comparison between the unprofessional Palestinian military, armed with unsophisticated weaponry, and Israel, whose army is equipped with F-16s from the U.S. and other supplies manufactured by numerous companies such as Micro Electronics and Motorola, in Arizona that produce defense-based electronics via military contracts.

The world must accept that Hamas won in clean elections with EU’s monitoring. But our reaction was immobilizing by allowing Israel to impose a crippling blockade in response. President George W. Bush justified the blockade by saying, “Israel has the right to protect itself.” Then, shortly after, America armed Hamas’ political rival to conduct a coup against elected Gazan officials while Israel arrested parliamentarians.

The important question is: are Palestinians entitled to the same basic human rights as other ethnic groups suffering displacement or discrimination? These rights  include the freedom of movement, access to food and the right to shelter one’s family. But how is the public supposed to be educated about these injustices if the U.S. media coverage reflects the U.S. political obligations?

According to national media watch group Fairness and Accuracy In Reporting, “U.S. corporate media coverage of the Israeli military attacks…has overwhelmingly failed to mention that indiscriminate attacks on civilian targets are illegal under international humanitarian law” after attacks in 2008. Only the Israeli narrative was conveyed in media, with information including: “Israel is being attacked using unprovoked rockets by Hamas the ‘terrorist’ organization.”  There was no mention that the majority of rockets were shot after Israel and the U.S. rejected the democratic process in Gaza or that Israel has broken more than 50 U.N. resolutions, conducted a humanitarianly illegal blockade against an entire population, killed 1,400 people and did not allow international media into Gaza during the Operation Cast Lead attack in 2008.
The U.N. Fact-Finding Mission on Gaza, headed by Richard Goldstone, a Jewish South African judge with strong personal ties to Israel and known for a sparring reputation in international law and human rights, concluded that Israel had used disproportionate force, targeted Palestinian civilians, using them as human shields and destroyed civilian infrastructure.

As a nation, we need to make a more conscious effort to divest from companies that manufacture products aiding Israeli occupation and learn to question the holes in media coverage of the Gaza Strip. We need to open our eyes.